...Continued from page 1

"Rich kid," said the youth with the papers. "Only jews live in the 16th." Then the aggressors became 'violent and sadistic.' They ripped her t–shirt and jeans, and held a blade to her cheek, and cut off a hank of hair, 'for a souvenir.' With a black marker they drew swastikas on Marie's bare stomach.

Marie's horror lasted 13 eternal minutes as the train passed the stations – Les Noues, Goussainville and Villier–le–Bel. At Garges–Sarcelles they pushed over the pousette, and left the train, taking Marie's back–pack. Luckily, the baby wasn't injured.

No passengers leaped forward to defend Marie, nobody pulled the alarm signal. Marie was unable to say how many other passengers had been riding in the same wagon. She guessed 20. The wagons have a capacity of 160, and the entire RER train can carry 1600 passengers. Even if there had been 20 passengers in the wagon, they might not have been close enough to witness the drama.

Shaken, Marie continued her journey to Gare du Nord and then switched to the Métro to ride out to Aubervilliers. It was here in the afternoon that Marie went to the police to press charges. She was examined by a doctor and declared unfit to work for 10 days.

Alerted by Pontoise, the Police Judiciaire of Versailles joined their colleagues at Cergy, to conduct the investigation. They weren't able to get a statement from Marie until Saturday afternoon. After listening for hours, they suggested that she avoid staying at home for security reasons. On Sunday night the Pontoise police asked for witnesses to step forward.

The investigators recuperated the tapes from the video cameras posted at the RER stations. They spoke to two passengers. Units of gendarmes, CRS, national police and railway cops spread out along the RER line looking for clues and additional witnesses.

Due to not being interrogated by police until Saturday afternoon the story was missed by the day's papers, but covered by TV–news Saturday evening.

Shortly after the story hit news agency wires, Minister of the Interior Dominique de Villepin condemned the 'ignoble' act, and minutes later Jacques Chirac said he was appalled.

By chance, Jacques Chirac had made a speech at Chambon–sur–Lignon on Thursday. This town in the Haute–Loire was being honored for receiving thousands of Jewishphoto: eiffel, before fireworks children during WWII and hiding them in the Haut–Lignon region from the Nazis. The president saluted the 'France fraternelle' in front of the villagers, accompanied by Simone Veil, Jacques Barrot, and Jérôme Monod – who had been one of the enfants.

Before the fireworks – like it is every night.

So it was that the outrage against antisemitism broke like a flood and reached heights seldom seen here by Sunday, which is the day that politicians are seen and heard by the media. Politicians of every stripe condemned the attack.

Last Monday Le Parisien gave some of its front page to the story, and all of its pages two, three and four. It listed no less than seven 'grave précédents' this year alone. On Monday the Communist Party led an pro–Jewish demonstration in Belleville. One banner read, 'Juifs et Arabes Pour la Justice.' The Elysée Palace let it be known that the 14. July presidential amnesty would not apply for racial crimes.

But by late Monday it was becoming apparent to the horde of investigators that there were problems with Marie's story. The police said the identities of witnesses would be kept confidential, but none came forward. The couple that Marie said aided her were equally unfindable. The half–dozen SNCF agents on the scene at the time, saw nothing.

Initial viewing of the videos from the stations revealed no images of any band of six youths, or of Marie. One investigator recalled that the swastikas drawn on Marie's tummy were backwards. One witness was found who said he saw Marie at Louvres with her pants already ripped. Her portable phone was checked, and was found to have been used for a call from Louvres station at the same time as Marie was being attacked on the train. The police began to doubt.

They discovered in their records that Marie had laid charges no less than five other times in the past, for attempted rape, aggression, violence – five complaints closed by police after follow–ups to nowhere.

By Wednesday Le Parisien's front page main headline was, "Mensonge(s)" Curiously, the photo just below the large type showed the movie 'Spiderman' attacking a commuter train.

Marie lied, the paper says. Held for interrogation, Marie spilled all the beans. The whole story was total fiction. School friends told the paper her nickname was 'Mytho.'

The first reaction to this was an answer to the question of why politicians had reacted so quickly, so unconditionly. Antisemitic acts this year are said to have increased four times over 2003. 'Foul' cried leaders of the Muslim community, with reason. The Prime Minister said the affair was a 'real emotion resulting from an event, real or virtual.'

By Thursday Marie had retreated to the Siberia of Le Parisien's page 11. She and her boyfriend were detained for a while on Wednesday and on Thursday authorities in Pontoise were trying to decide what to do. Marie's mother had been interviewed on radio RTL, saying that if her daughter was to be judged, she should be treated too.

The embarrassment was embarrassing. Were the president and other notables too swift with their condemnations? Since the perceived abandonment of the aged during the heat wave last summer, all politicians have attempted to seem more alert to the concerns of the French.

Finally, on Thursday night's TV–news and on Friday morning's Le Parisien front page, we saw the photos of Marie outside the Hôtel de Police at Cergy. She has been charged with making 'charges of fake crimes.' She risks six months in jail and a fine of 7500€, but was set free to await a hearing later this month.

Most likely, if Marie seeks psychiatric help, the court will be lenient. This is what her mother hopes, and what is most likely to happen because Marie has confessed all of her 'crimes' to the police.

Marie is an attractive, well–dressed young lady with a young baby. Judging from all the times they have been mentioned, I suspect she has made enough confessions to last her a lifetime. To these she has added her excuses, made publically to the newspapers and on television.

Trip of the Lip?

Yesterday, speaking in Israel to representatives of American jewish organizations, Prime Minister Ariel Sharon said that immigration to Israel was the sole response to 'an unfettered antisemitism that is spreading in France.' He added that he thought French Jews would be wise to 'move immediately.'

'Ten percent of the population of France consists of Muslims, supplying fertilizer for a new form of antisemitism,' the Israeli leader contended.

The French reaction was swift. 'Unacceptable' said the foreign minister, Michel Barnier, who asked French representatives to contact Israeli authorities quickly for 'explanations.'

Théo Klein, honorary president of the council representing French jewish institutions, said he thought Sharon should let French jews handle their own problems. Patrick Gaubert, president of the International League Against Racism and Antisemitism, judged that, 'Mr. Sharon would do better to shut up, because his proposals do not bring the calm, peace or serenity we all need.'

'Very badly informed,' considered Patrick Klugman, vice–president of SOS Racisme, 'about what's going on in France. Very badly informed about the reality of the Jews of France who are above all happy to be able to live here, happy with a government that protects them.'

It is difficult the evaluate the effect of antisemitism in France on emigration to Israel. According to the Jewish Agency, in 2003 there were 2 313 French emigres, and 2566 in 2002, but these were 2.5 times more compared to 2000/2001. In all, 70,000 French Jews have moved to Israel since 1948. This is hardly an exodus.

It is thought that France's jewish population numbers about 600,000. After Israel and the United States, it is thephoto: marianne stamp, assembly national world's third largest Jewish community. Some French observers think that the Jewish Agency seeks to motivate French Jews to emigrate because of falling immigration from Russia and Argentina.

Display of new Marianne stamp on the Assembly National.

The 'invitation' has been made before, most notably on 6. January 2002, when the vice–minister of Israeli foreign affairs, Michael Melchior, stated that 'France was the worst country in the world when it comes to antisemitism.'

According the French interior ministry there have been 135 antisemitic acts since the beginning of the year, compared to 127 in 2003 and 192 in 2002.

The weekend marked the sad memorial of the 'Roundup of the Vélodrôme d'Hiver' – 'Rafle du Vel' d'Hiv' – in July 1942, when 12,884 Jews in the Paris region were rounded up and arrested by Vichy's police. Many were interned, but 8000 were sent to Drancy and then on one–way trips to death camps in eastern Europe.

The memorial ceremonies of the 62nd anniversary coincided with the 'Journée nationale à la mémoire des victimes des crimes racistes et antisémites et d'hommage aux 'Justes' de France.'

horz line
Go to page : 1 - 2
In Metropole Paris
Latest Issue
2008 Issues
2007 | 2006 | 2005
2004 | 2003 | 2002
2001 | 2000 | 1999
1998 | 1997 | 1996
In Metropole Paris
About Metropole
About the Café Club
Links | Search Site
The Lodging Page
Paris Museums List
Metropole's 1996 Tours
Metropole's 2003 Tours
Support Metropole
Metropole's Books
Shop with Metropole
Metropole's Wine
metropole paris goodblogweek button
Send email concerning the
contents to: Ric Erickson, Editor.
Metropole Midi © 2014
– unless stated otherwise.
logo, metropole sml midi logo No matter how good it tastes,
there is no such thing
as a free lunch.
Waldo Bini